大學生英語辯論賽話題集錦(MP3+中英字幕) 第44場:人肉搜尋是否是網路私刑

For:

正方辯詞：

Human flesh search: the "Vigilante of Chinese Internet".

人肉搜尋:網際網路的義務警員。

In my opinion, the "human fresh search" is the online vigilante. With convenience of the Internet, the righteous people take matters into their own hands and seek justice on the Internet. More and more people who be have irrelevantly(不恰當的) or commit crimes are found and punished by public. As a result, human flesh search is helpful in keeping justice online.

我認為，"人肉搜尋"在網路中起著"網路義警"的作用。隨著網路的越發便利，一些正義之士主動承擔此任，自發地在網上尋找正義。所以，越來越多的不法犯罪行為被搜尋到並曝光於大庭廣眾之下，受到了應有的制裁。因此，"人肉搜尋"有助於維護網路上的正義。

Against:

反方辯詞：

Human flesh search: a kind of "Internet Iynching".

人肉搜尋:網際網路的網路私刑。

I think human flesh search is a kind of Internet lynching. Privacy is the basic right for everyone, even for the criminal. Therefore, the action of cyber violence and privacy violation should not be encouraged by the public.

我認為"人肉搜尋"是一種"網路私刑"。個人隱私權是每個人包括罪犯應享有的基本權利。因此，我們不應該鼓勵這種網路暴力和侵犯隱私的行為。

What's more, human flesh search can be misused on purpose. If you don't like someone, you can lie about him. So strangers will attack him, which will bring the innocent a lot of troubles.

另外，"人肉搜尋"會被一些別有目的者利用。如果你討厭某個人，就可以誣賴他。然後一些不知情的人便會攻擊他，這會讓無辜者陷入極大的困境。